Blue Lady Room

A cozy room above the old General Store, in the center of town. This room was named after the “Blue Lady,” a ghost documented in guest books over many years. The Blue Lady can supposedly be summoned by turning on the blue light next to the bed. The room has windows facing West, South and North and a lovely private deck overlooking the Winegarten and Story’s herb garden. The room has a queen-sized bed and a spacious bathroom with a standing shower. Boooo!

Premium: $169
Peak: $149
Non-Peak: $109 PLUS TAX
Maximum occupancy: two.


The price above is exclusive of taxes and based upon double occupancy. There is a charge of $15.00 for each additional person, not to exceed the maximum occupancy of the room, as noted. Children ten and under who do not need bedding are free.

Check-in is anytime after 3:00 p.m., and check-out by 11:00 a.m., unless you make other arrangements with us. We do not permit pets in the Blue Lady room.

If you intend to enjoy breakfast with us, you may purchase a “Bed & Breakfast Package” at $9/person, which will enable you to order any food and beverage from the regular breakfast menu (except for alcoholic beverages). You may order the “Bed & Breakfast Package” by calling (800) 881-1183, or requesting it at the time you check in.

Questions? Please feel free to e-mail the Story Inn,

: 1-812-988-2273.


  • Lieber Room $139.00

  • Morrision-Kelly Room $139.00

  • Hedrick Room $139.00

  • Schultz Haus Front $199.00

  • Schultz Haus Back $159.00

  • Wheeler Front $159.00

  • Wheeler Back $179.00

  • Wilkerson Front $179.00

  • Wilkerson Back $179.00

  • Carriage House $199.00

  • Old Mill Loft $199.00

  • Treaty House $199.00

  • Garrison: Gunflint $199.00

  • Garrison: Tree House $199.00

  • Garrison: Durango $179.00

  • Garrison: Tack Room $179.00

(Above prices are Peak Rates. Lower Non-Peak rates may apply)

Make a reservation

Room Booking form
Katapult MarketingBlue Lady Room